Some thoughts on Secondary Progressions…who needs transits? Part One

‘I would love to live like a river flows, carried by the surprise of its own unfolding.’ John O’Donohue

Consider this surprise. Astrology textbooks tell you that the planets from Jupiter outwards move so slowly by progression that their shifts are of no consequence. On the very day in June 2016 that my third house Jupiter moved by secondary progression from life-long occupancy of Scorpio into Sagittarius, I was offered a large library of astrology books from a university lecturer whose wife, a keen student of astrology, had recently died.

“Phoebe” a participant in the 1997/8 research I did on Jupiter/Uranus conjunctions, started piano lessons for the first time and became very interested in fashion/image in 1997, the year her natal Neptune in Libra went direct by secondary progression. No doubt readers could add their own examples of progressed planetary effects which supposedly are of no consequence!


I am very well aware that there are several ways of progressing a horoscope which are no doubt valid. However, traditional Secondary Progressions or SPs as I shall now call them for short, are the only type which have consistently spoken to me with great accuracy. These are calculated by moving the planetary positions in the ephemeris for the day of birth forward one day for every year of a person’s life, offering a means of determining the timing, and understanding the meaning, of significant developmental points in that individual’s unique unfolding journey.

In this article, I am not proposing to reinvent the astro-wheel by offering detailed tuition on what SPs are, how to calculate them, work with them, and relate them to whatever transits may be in operation at any given time. There is plenty of information of that type available on the Web, as a quick Google search will reveal. However, my USA colleague Dawn Bodrogi in my estimation has done the finest recent work on the topic. You can find her writing at The Inner Wheel (1).

Instead, my aim is to offer a personal reflection on Secondary Progressions, continuing in the same spirit as the opening paragraph. I’d like to share my clients’ experiences of those mysterious symbolic tools, as well as my own. My observations are also offered to experienced practitioners in such a way that they can take a moment: to step back from their astro-toolkit and be freshly awestruck by the essential Mystery which SPs evoke.

Most of all, I’d like to intrigue and inspire readers who are fairly new to astrology to begin their own journey into this misty, awesome territory.

From the time I discovered SPs as a Faculty of Astrological Studies student in the 1980s, they have fascinated me. This fascination was amplified as I slowly became an experienced astrology teacher, using my classes (as you do) for the brilliant qualitative research opportunities ‘on the hoof’  that they undoubtedly provide.

When you first go round a class of a dozen students, tracking their Suns changing signs by secondary progression, discovering their corresponding life changes as well as your own, it does rather cause you to scratch your head – after you and your students have come down from the sheer buzz of it all – and ask “But why does astrology work ?And why does a purely symbolic technique like SPs seem to work too ?” 

Help is at hand – from quantum science

Ancient Stargazers

Ancient Stargazers

Good questions, which astrologers have been asking for centuries, millennia probably, ever since those Chaldean priests on their chilly watchtowers scanned the night skies for helpful advance warning signs that their kings and kingdoms were under threat. I do not propose in this short article to add to the vast amounts of erudite speculation which has arisen from such questions.

However, very briefly, my conclusion is this: modern science has demonstrated that we live, move and have our being as part of a vast energy field which ripples and changes in a sinuous, shapeshifting dance between order and chaos, order arising out of apparent disorder, in invisible patterns which would appear to hold 4 % matter, 23 % dark matter, and 73 % dark energy together in a vast cosmic web.

I think that astrology works by tracking and mapping those energy patterns through planetary cycles against the backdrop of either the constellations via sidereal astrology, or our more familiar tropical astrology which is pegged to the ecliptic. By a blend of astronomical calculation, mythic imagination, intuition, and observation of correlations between life on Earth and planetary movements over millennia, humans arrived at a way of deriving meaning from the energies generating the solar system, our tiny corner of that vast cosmic web.

It is no surprise that reductionist thinking cannot cope with the possibility that something of great value to the human project could have arisen from this eclectic weave.

There are several ways in which one can creatively reflect upon that 4%, 23% and 73 % ratio. I like to think of it in terms of the worlds of consciousness, personal unconscious and collective unconscious, finding Jung’s term ‘psychoid’ very useful in enabling me to make sense of energies which can and do manifest simultaneously, all the way from very obvious and tangible to being highly influential in a person’s life although invisible to the wider world.

For example, consider the client I saw some years ago with a dominant Saturn square Neptune aspect in his horoscope. “James” ’ profession was highly tangible: he made musical instruments. But a significant factor in the unfolding pattern of his life, also linked to that Saturn/Neptune square, was his having had to survive growing up with a severely alcoholic father. Being very aware of an inherited tendency to indulge in addictive escapist behaviours, he was trying to address this when he came for a consultation – as his secondary progressed Sun triggered natal Saturn square Neptune.

I think that an important part of the creative value of being a practising astrologer lies in helping clients like James to understand, accept and work constructively with the shape-shifting potential inherent in the particular energies with which they came into the world.

From the above perspective very briefly outlined, it isn’t too difficult to tie in the planetary patterns in the sky here-and-now to the static picture of the natal horoscope. You are working, at least in part, with what you can actually see. However, in working with SPs, you are stepping into the mysterious, intangible world of the purely symbolic.

I find that my (metaphorical at least!) understanding of that 4%, 23% and 73 % ratio is very helpful in feeling comfortable with such mysterious territory. That which cannot be seen, perceived or understood via our five senses within the 4% world of matter, still has energetic validity in the landscape of the unseen 96% – that which modern science tells us is there, although we can only perceive it by inference and don’t yet know what it is.

Secondary progressions and family inheritance

The most striking example of  the mysterious power of SPs that I have ever had, occurred a number of years ago when I was playing around with the weave of interconnectedness which you find as soon as you begin to spend time looking at family horoscopes.

Having acquired the birth certificates of all four of my grandparents, three with accurately recorded birth times, and having calculated their horoscopes, I took a notion to progress the birth charts of the two grandparents who had been most significant for me, and whose characteristics I most clearly recognised blended in myself, ie my maternal grandfather Calum and my paternal grandmother Isabella – both born in different years at different times. I progressed their charts, both with accurate birth times, to the day of my own birth.

The result stunned me. BOTH grandparents’ progressed Ascendants were 9 degrees Virgo, BOTH progressed Midheavens were 28 degrees Taurus. And my Angles? Yes, you’ve guessed it. My natal Ascendant is 9 degrees Virgo, and natal Midheaven is 28 degrees Taurus. My North Node is also 28 Taurus – and my pre-natal solar eclipse is 28 degrees Taurus, thereby emphasising the significance of the IC/MC axis in the transmission of family fate, karma, genetic inheritance or whatever you wish to term it. I have written about this before, and described my feeling then of having been ‘brushed by the wing of a great Mystery’(2).

Recently, whilst thinking about this article, I re-calculated that set of progressions, just in case I had somehow made a mistake all those years ago. The result was the same.

Part Two of this post follows shortly. As ever, your comments/feedback are most welcome.



This two-part post was first published as Secondary Progressions – stepping into the Mystery  in the May/June 2017 Issue of the UK’s Astrological Journal, edited by Victor Olliver.

(1)The Inner Wheel:

(2) Unfortunately, I can’t now recall where!




1500 words copyright Anne Whitaker 2017

24 responses to “Some thoughts on Secondary Progressions…who needs transits? Part One

  1. I’m very intrigued, especially with what you did with your grandparents charts. My first grandchild is due in Nov. and I’m wondering if I can use my chart & my husband’s to calculate the baby’s chart before her arrival. We are very likely to be her closest grandparents. Fascinating experiment!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Glad you liked the post, Ellis, and congratulations on your impending grandchild. We have a six-year-old granddaughter and she is a real joy. Yes, I’d be interested to see the results of your experiment in relation to your grandchild’s chart, and especially the Angles. However, I’d be most surprised if the same thing happened with you – no wonder astrology has the reductionists frothing at the mouth! – but there will certainly be strong symbolic similarities of some kind – eg a grandparents’ Angles in the same sign(s) as eg the child’s sun or moon. Do remember to report back!


  2. Just recently, my progressed Sun moved ahead of my progressed Asc into the first house, and recently entered Libra. My progressed Moon just entered Scorpio. I certainly hope that new and better things are on the way into my life. The last 5 years have been relentless. Thank you for this article.

    Liked by 1 person

    • You are welcome, Martha. I am sorry to hear that things have been so difficult for you recently. Just going on the small amount of detail you’ve given me, assuming your birth time is accurate(since even a few minutes out can slightly change the Ascendant and Midheaven), you are now at the start of a progressed New Moon (Sun in Libra, Moon ahead of the Sun, in Scorpio). The Sun now in the first house indicates that Sun’s long transit of your 12th House – often a difficult time – is complete. So – bon voyage into this new phase…


      • By transit, Pluto is opp natal Mercury, Chiron opp natal Moon and Saturn is conjunct natal Jupiter. That’s felt oppressive… and it feels like I’m just wandering around the rubble of all that fell apart in 2012, waiting for the celestial insurance money to come and the construction team to arrive for building the next phase of life. This too shall pass, hopefully soon if progressions are stronger than transits. Because those transits still have a ways to go until they pull away.


      • Yes, this does look hard, Martha. Having been through what feels more than my share of really tough, prolonged periods of demolition by transit myself I am not about to offer you any glib statements of consolation. However, I will say that progressions seem to be very accurate at mapping the unfolding life pattern in the background of our lives, its deeper process, with transits providing the foreground challenges. When a new progressed Sun/Moon cycle begins its 30-year unfolding it takes some time for the new life phase to take shape. So, be patient, and do the best you can in the present. I don’t know if it’s any comfort, but I had ten years of Neptune oppositions to my Twelfth House planets whilst Neptune was going through Aquarius, as well as the ending of an old progressed Sun/Moon cycle. I was in retreat of necessity from 2001-6 when my progressed New Moon in Libra ( like yours) took place. Over ten years later, I feel better than I ever have…Every good wish with it all. As you say, all things pass…


  3. Via Facebook:
    Linda Reid:
    Love SPs in my own work, but never thought to look at inheritance this way. How lucky to have birth times Anne


  4. Yes indeed, Linda. The weather in Scotland may be awful, but it’s great being an astrologer here with accurate birth times available!


  5. Via Facebook:
    Evelyn Herbertz:
    Anne, have I mentioned that I recently noticed that my SP Venus will be conjunct my natal Jupiter in Taurus in my 2nd House in a couple years?


  6. You certainly have, Evelyn! Quite envious of that one, personally…do remember to send me some feedback!☀️


  7. Via Facebook:
    Sellieve Neptune:
    That’s too coincidental to not be real!


  8. Yes, Sellieve, wouldn’t it be great to run a qualitative research study between grandparents and their grandchildren? Wish I had the time!


  9. Via Facebook:
    30.7.17:Rena Hdesign:
    Brilliant post Anne! There is nothing I like better than the kind of writing you do that goes straight to the heart of it – and your explanation of the mysteries and the way you understand astrology to work does just that. What a fascinating way to look at it! I’ve had the pleasure of learning some about Dawn Bodrogi’s work with Secondary Progressions – and her work/writing rings with the same inherent comprehension evolved from years of painstaking practical application. Whenever anyone looks sideways at my love for astrology – which can be a little intimidating at times – I remind myself of those whose footsteps I’m following in:)


  10. Many thanks for this lovely affirmation, Rena. Just keep going with your astrology – the sideways lookers have absolutely no idea of the richness they are missing!


  11. Via Facebook:
    Morgana Dee:
    Excellent article Anne. I too have been fascinated by progressions since the mid-eighties. One of the most interesting progressions for me was when my daughter was conceived rather unexpectedly at age 39. I spent an hour with a guy and that was very unexpected as well so much to my shock, despite dreaming about this child for two years, I found out almost two and half months later that I was pregnant. Progressed Sun as it turns out happened to be my daughter’s Moon degree at birth, but opposite. Progressed Venus was conjunct my Jupiter within 9 minutes when she was born. Progressed Moon was also conjunct my MC within a degree when she was conceived. There is much more but those ones really impressed me. My Sun went into Aries in 1995 and my life changed, but then that does square my natal Uranus.

    Another progression happening now [exact last night], and which I told you about is SP Moon exactly conjuncted my Progressed Sun at 9:41pm yesterday and during the night I felt the shift, especially in how I felt when waking, more alert and not so sick as I have been the last three months. During this dark moon time I broke a rib, had an asthma attack which moved my lungs and I have been battling that one feeling sicker every day, even yesterday, so it was a great surprise to feel so much better this morning with a break in the fever. Progressed Jupiter moved into Pisces earlier this year and trines natal Uranus within a degree but it moves slowly so probably not exact for 3 years or so but within orb now. I have transit Jupiter when it gets up to 23 Libra setting off my Directed Jupiter-Pluto opposition and that is rather exciting I feel because I have transits, progressions and directions all being triggered now and the next year. Sorry this is so long.


  12. Thanks so much, Morgana, for this very illustrative feedback. As I was saying to another commenter here, I too found the Moondark period up until New Moon in 2006 very difficult and testing – but ultimately very enriching, especially in long retrospect…!!


  13. Pingback: Working with Secondary Progressions: focus on progressed New Moons | Astrology: Questions and Answers

  14. 17:
    Linda Reid:
    Love SPs in my own work, but never thought to look at inheritance this way. Just going on the small amount of detail you’ve given me, assuming your birth time is accurate(since even a few minutes out can slightly change the Ascendant and Midheaven), you are now at the start of a progressed New Moon (Sun in Libra, Moon ahead of the Sun, in Scorpio).


  15. Whenever anyone looks sideways at my love for astrology – which can be a little intimidating at times – I remind myself of those whose footsteps I’m following in:) There is much more but those ones really impressed me.

    Liked by 1 person

  16. There is much more but those ones really impressed(p) me. Progressed Sun as it turns out happened to be my daughter’s Moon academic degree at parentage, but diametrical.

    Liked by 1 person

  17. Great article 👌🙂. I think that secondary progressions are extremely underrated in the astro world. I’m not big into astrology as I once was in the past, but I can’t deny how prominent my progressions became in my own personality, that it was also life changing in a way.

    Liked by 1 person

  18. Thanks for this feedback, Jen.I agree with you re secondary progressions. I think they are wonderfully relevant, accurate and helpful in making sense of my own and others’ unfolding life pattern…


Leave a Reply to ellisnelson Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.